2025_NIPS_Judging LLM-as-a-Judge with MT-Bench and Chatbot Arena

文章核心总结与创新点

一、主要内容

本文聚焦大语言模型(LLM)聊天助手的评估难题,针对传统基准无法有效衡量人类偏好与模型对齐度的问题,提出并系统研究了“LLM-as-a-Judge”(以强LLM作为评估者)的评估方法,同时构建了两个新型基准数据集MT-bench和Chatbot Arena,最终验证了该评估方法的有效性与实用性。

  1. 评估现状与问题:传统LLM基准(如MMLU、HELM)仅关注模型核心能力(如知识问答),无法区分经过人类反馈强化学习(RLHF)对齐后的模型与基础模型,存在人类偏好感知与基准评估标准的脱节。
  2. 新型基准构建:
    • MT-bench:包含80个高质量多轮开放式问题,覆盖写作、推理、数学、编码等8个类别,用于评估模型的多轮对话与指令遵循能力。
    • Chatbot Arena:众包对战平台,用户同时与两个匿名模型交互并投票偏好,收集了3万条真实场景下的人类偏好数据。
  3. LLM-as-a-Judge方法:
    • 提出三种评估变体: pairwise comparison( pairwise比较)、single answer grading(单答案评分)、reference-guided grading(参考引导评分)。
    • 分析核心局限:存在位置偏差、冗长偏差、自我增强偏差,以及数学/推理问题评估能力不
Judging LLM-as-a-Judge with MT-Bench and Chatbot Arena阅读笔记 MT-Bench 和 Chatbot Arena 是两个用于评估 LLM 聊天助手的新基准,分别侧重于多回合对话的质量和真实用户偏好。这两个基准的设计初衷是弥补现有基准在评估聊天助手人类偏好方面的不足,提供更准确和全面的评估方法。MMLU:重点评估模型在多任务、多领域的知识和理解能力。HELM:提供一个多维度的评估框架,全面评估模型的性能和实际应用中的各种表现。这两个基准各有侧重,MMLU 更关注模型的知识广度和准确性,而 HELM 则提供了一个全面的评估框架,涵盖了模型在实际应用中的多方面表现。 阅读详情

相关推荐

「文智助手」全场景办公AI助理AI+OPC全流程实践方案(大赛作品)

「文智助手」全场景办公AI助理AI+OPC全流程实践方案(大赛作品)

jks212454的博客 420

船载 OpenHarmony AIS 航海工作台:告警与防碰撞预警系统

船载OpenHarmony AIS航海工作台的告警与防碰撞系统,集成十余类告警(超速、偏航、会遇、SOS等),通过网格空间索引实现高效邻近判定,保障实时性。告警管理器统一调度规则、去重、通知与日志,支持悬浮球、语音、跑马灯、弹窗多渠道触达,确保航行安全。SOS紧急通道独立运行,避免干扰。系统设计强调性能优化与多场景适配,为航海安全提供核心支撑。

专注于计算机研发知识和资讯分享 438

ADS SerDes仿真实战:深入解析Tx_Diff均衡器(EQ)参数对眼图质量的影响

本文以ADS仿真平台为基础,深入解析了SerDes设计中Tx_Diff均衡器(EQ)参数对信号完整性的核心影响。通过实战演示,详细对比了去加重(De-emphasis)与FIR抽头系数两种调节模式,揭示了它们如何有效对抗信道损耗与码间干扰,从而显著改善眼图的高度、宽度与抖动性能,为高速串行链路设计提供关键调优思路。

weixin_29230901的博客 229

【GAN实战】基于pytorch-CycleGAN与pix2pix的自定义数据集训练全攻略

本文详细解析了基于PyTorch的CycleGAN与pix2pix模型在自定义数据集上的完整训练流程。核心在于根据数据是否成对来正确选择模型:pix2pix适用于严格配对的“孪生”数据,而CycleGAN则擅长处理非配对的“散装”数据集。文章从数据准备、配置训练到测试应用,提供了全链路实战指南与关键参数调优心得,帮助开发者高效实现图像到图像的风格转换。

x2y3z4a5b的博客 704

《工程测量学》笔记/期末复习资料

《工程测量学》笔记/期末复习资料。

@HNUSTer的博客 5567

华为云Stack的学习(三)

LVS是四层负载均衡,建立在OSI模型的传输层之上,所以效率非常高。NAT模式的转发主要通过修改IP地址(位于OSI模型的第三层网络层)实现转发。DR模式的转发主要通过修改MAC地址(位于OSI模型的第二层数据链路层)实现转发。云服务框架中使用的DR模式。域名解析服务器分为管理侧(OM)和租户侧(Tenant)**DNS-OM:**作为云服务的本地DNS服务器,为云服务提供域名解析服务,并代理公网域名的解析。

Ciyaso的博客 8562

一文入门Qwen-Agent【附实战代码】

Qwen-Agent 是一个开源框架,用于开发基于 Qwen 模型的 AI 智能体应用,一文带你入门使用

m0_55303420的博客 1875

ZYNQ-7035+HMCAD1511高速数据采集系统设计

高速数据采集是电子测量、雷达信号处理与通信基带验证的核心技术基础,其性能瓶颈常集中于采样率、通道同步性与实时处理能力。基于ADC采样原理与SoC异构架构,高带宽、低抖动时钟链路与FPGA+ARM协同处理成为突破关键。ZYNQ-7035凭借275K逻辑单元与千级DSP资源,显著提升LVDS数据流吞吐与片上滤波/触发等实时算法部署能力;HMCAD1511则以1GSPS四通道同步采样和8位分辨率,满足示波器级动态范围需求。该组合广泛应用于嵌入式信号采集平台开发、教学实验系统构建及国产化仪器原型验证。

weixin_28939623的博客 262

知识追踪实战:lstm+ Multi-head Attention注意力机制的学生做题成绩预测实战

知识追踪实战:lstm+ Multi-head Attention注意力机制的学生做题成绩预测实战

2222

Python DEAP 库深度解析:从基础架构到高级应用

DEAP 是一个基于 Python 的开源框架,专门用于实现和运行各种进化算法,旨在帮助用户轻松地构建和调整进化算法,用于解决各种优化和搜索问题。本节中,介绍了 DEAP 相较于其它进化计算框架的优势,以及 DEAP 中重要的工具 creator 和 Toolbox。

盼小辉丶的博客 5139

假人有限元模型

假人模型,车辆碰撞假人有限元模型,适合做乘员安全的研究者利用

win10 跳过U8环境检测的IE WebControls.rar

win10 安装u8的时候 提示IE WebControls 不通过,这个工具可以欺骗u8的检查。 跳过U8环境检测的IE WebControls。提示导入失败后,重新检测通过。

深度学习工具包 DeepLearningToolbox

深度学习工具包Deprecation notice.-----This toolbox is outdated and no longer maintained.There are much better tools available for deep learning than this toolbox, e.g. [Theano](http://deeplearning.net/software/theano/), [torch](http://torch.ch/) or [tensorflow](http://www.tensorflow.org/)I would suggest you use one of the tools mentioned above rather than use this toolbox.Best, Rasmus.DeepLearnToolbox================A Matlab toolbox for Deep Learning.Deep Learning is a new subfield of machine learning that focuses on learning deep hierarchical models of data.It is inspired by the human brain's apparent deep (layered, hierarchical) architecture.A good overview of the theory of Deep Learning theory is[Learning Deep Architectures for AI](http://www.iro.umontreal.ca/~bengioy/papers/ftml_book.pdf)For a more informal introduction, see the following videos by Geoffrey Hinton and Andrew Ng.* [The Next Generation of Neural Networks](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AyzOUbkUf3M) (Hinton, 2007)* [Recent Developments in Deep Learning](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdIURAu1-aU) (Hinton, 2010)* [Unsupervised Feature Learning and Deep Learning](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmNOAtZIgIk) (Ng, 2011)If you use this toolbox in your research please cite [Prediction as a candidate for learning deep hierarchical models of data](http://www2.imm.dtu.dk/pubdb/views/publication_details.php?id=6284)```@MASTERSTHESIS\{IMM2012-06284, author = "R. B. Palm", title = "Prediction as a candidate for learning deep hierarchical models of data", year = "2012",}```Contact: rasmusbergpalm at gmail dot comDirectories included in the toolbox-----------------------------------`NN/` - A library for Feedforward Backpropagation Neural Networks`CNN/` - A library for Convolutional Neural Networks`DBN/` - A library for Deep Belief Networks`SAE/` - A library for Stacked Auto-Encoders`CAE/` - A library for Convolutional Auto-Encoders`util/` - Utility functions used by the libraries`data/` - Data used by the examples`tests/` - unit tests to verify toolbox is workingFor references on each library check REFS.mdSetup-----1. Download.2. addpath(genpath('DeepLearnToolbox'));Example: Deep Belief Network---------------------```matlabfunction test_example_DBNload mnist_uint8;train_x = double(train_x) / 255;test_x = double(test_x) / 255;train_y = double(train_y);test_y = double(test_y);%% ex1 train a 100 hidden unit RBM and visualize its weightsrand('state',0)dbn.sizes = [100];opts.numepochs = 1;opts.batchsize = 100;opts.momentum = 0;opts.alpha = 1;dbn = dbnsetup(dbn, train_x, opts);dbn = dbntrain(dbn, train_x, opts);figure; visualize(dbn.rbm{1}.W'); % Visualize the RBM weights%% ex2 train a 100-100 hidden unit DBN and use its weights to initialize a NNrand('state',0)%train dbndbn.sizes = [100 100];opts.numepochs = 1;opts.batchsize = 100;opts.momentum = 0;opts.alpha = 1;dbn = dbnsetup(dbn, train_x, opts);dbn = dbntrain(dbn, train_x, opts);%unfold dbn to nnnn = dbnunfoldtonn(dbn, 10);nn.activation_function = 'sigm';%train nnopts.numepochs = 1;opts.batchsize = 100;nn = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.10, 'Too big error');```Example: Stacked Auto-Encoders---------------------```matlabfunction test_example_SAEload mnist_uint8;train_x = double(train_x)/255;test_x = double(test_x)/255;train_y = double(train_y);test_y = double(test_y);%% ex1 train a 100 hidden unit SDAE and use it to initialize a FFNN% Setup and train a stacked denoising autoencoder (SDAE)rand('state',0)sae = saesetup([784 100]);sae.ae{1}.activation_function = 'sigm';sae.ae{1}.learningRate = 1;sae.ae{1}.inputZeroMaskedFraction = 0.5;opts.numepochs = 1;opts.batchsize = 100;sae = saetrain(sae, train_x, opts);visualize(sae.ae{1}.W{1}(:,2:end)')% Use the SDAE to initialize a FFNNnn = nnsetup([784 100 10]);nn.activation_function = 'sigm';nn.learningRate = 1;nn.W{1} = sae.ae{1}.W{1};% Train the FFNNopts.numepochs = 1;opts.batchsize = 100;nn = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.16, 'Too big error');```Example: Convolutional Neural Nets---------------------```matlabfunction test_example_CNNload mnist_uint8;train_x = double(reshape(train_x',28,28,60000))/255;test_x = double(reshape(test_x',28,28,10000))/255;train_y = double(train_y');test_y = double(test_y');%% ex1 Train a 6c-2s-12c-2s Convolutional neural network %will run 1 epoch in about 200 second and get around 11% error. %With 100 epochs you'll get around 1.2% errorrand('state',0)cnn.layers = { struct('type', 'i') %input layer struct('type', 'c', 'outputmaps', 6, 'kernelsize', 5) %convolution layer struct('type', 's', 'scale', 2) %sub sampling layer struct('type', 'c', 'outputmaps', 12, 'kernelsize', 5) %convolution layer struct('type', 's', 'scale', 2) %subsampling layer};cnn = cnnsetup(cnn, train_x, train_y);opts.alpha = 1;opts.batchsize = 50;opts.numepochs = 1;cnn = cnntrain(cnn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = cnntest(cnn, test_x, test_y);%plot mean squared errorfigure; plot(cnn.rL);assert(er<0.12, 'Too big error');```Example: Neural Networks---------------------```matlabfunction test_example_NNload mnist_uint8;train_x = double(train_x) / 255;test_x = double(test_x) / 255;train_y = double(train_y);test_y = double(test_y);% normalize[train_x, mu, sigma] = zscore(train_x);test_x = normalize(test_x, mu, sigma);%% ex1 vanilla neural netrand('state',0)nn = nnsetup([784 100 10]);opts.numepochs = 1; % Number of full sweeps through dataopts.batchsize = 100; % Take a mean gradient step over this many samples[nn, L] = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.08, 'Too big error');%% ex2 neural net with L2 weight decayrand('state',0)nn = nnsetup([784 100 10]);nn.weightPenaltyL2 = 1e-4; % L2 weight decayopts.numepochs = 1; % Number of full sweeps through dataopts.batchsize = 100; % Take a mean gradient step over this many samplesnn = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.1, 'Too big error');%% ex3 neural net with dropoutrand('state',0)nn = nnsetup([784 100 10]);nn.dropoutFraction = 0.5; % Dropout fraction opts.numepochs = 1; % Number of full sweeps through dataopts.batchsize = 100; % Take a mean gradient step over this many samplesnn = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.1, 'Too big error');%% ex4 neural net with sigmoid activation functionrand('state',0)nn = nnsetup([784 100 10]);nn.activation_function = 'sigm'; % Sigmoid activation functionnn.learningRate = 1; % Sigm require a lower learning rateopts.numepochs = 1; % Number of full sweeps through dataopts.batchsize = 100; % Take a mean gradient step over this many samplesnn = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.1, 'Too big error');%% ex5 plotting functionalityrand('state',0)nn = nnsetup([784 20 10]);opts.numepochs = 5; % Number of full sweeps through datann.output = 'softmax'; % use softmax outputopts.batchsize = 1000; % Take a mean gradient step over this many samplesopts.plot = 1; % enable plottingnn = nntrain(nn, train_x, train_y, opts);[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.1, 'Too big error');%% ex6 neural net with sigmoid activation and plotting of validation and training error% split training data into training and validation datavx = train_x(1:10000,:);tx = train_x(10001:end,:);vy = train_y(1:10000,:);ty = train_y(10001:end,:);rand('state',0)nn = nnsetup([784 20 10]); nn.output = 'softmax'; % use softmax outputopts.numepochs = 5; % Number of full sweeps through dataopts.batchsize = 1000; % Take a mean gradient step over this many samplesopts.plot = 1; % enable plottingnn = nntrain(nn, tx, ty, opts, vx, vy); % nntrain takes validation set as last two arguments (optionally)[er, bad] = nntest(nn, test_x, test_y);assert(er < 0.1, 'Too big error');```[![Bitdeli Badge](https://d2weczhvl823v0.cloudfront.net/rasmusbergpalm/deeplearntoolbox/trend.png)](https://bitdeli.com/free "Bitdeli Badge")

上一篇: 2025_NIPS_Suggesting Variable Order for Cylindrical Algebraic Decomposition via Reinforcement Lea...
下一篇: 2025_NIPS_Policy Optimization for Continuous Reinforcement Learning
UnknownBody
博客等级 码龄16年 5601粉丝 4749原创
评论
成就一亿技术人!
拼手气红包6.0元
还能输入1000个字符
 
 条评论被折叠 查看
添加红包

请填写红包祝福语或标题

个

红包个数最小为10个

元

红包金额最低5元

当前余额3.43元 前往充值 >
需支付:10.00元
成就一亿技术人!
领取后你会自动成为博主和红包主的粉丝 规则
hope_wisdom
发出的红包

打赏作者

UnknownBody

你的鼓励将是我创作的最大动力

¥1 ¥2 ¥4 ¥6 ¥10 ¥20
扫码支付:¥1
获取中
扫码支付

您的余额不足,请更换扫码支付或充值

打赏作者

实付元
使用余额支付
点击重新获取
扫码支付
钱包余额 0

抵扣说明:

1.余额是钱包充值的虚拟货币,按照1:1的比例进行支付金额的抵扣。
2.余额无法直接购买下载,可以购买VIP、付费专栏及课程。

余额充值