阿里旷视 百度 OCR图片文字识别功能对比
因为项目中需要用到图片转文字的功能看到网上有挺多这方面的API 所以测试下哪个产品的功能更好目前选中了阿里 旷视 和百度这三家的API
图片:
旷视识别出来的结果
句对起
沨1当初的爱你
下面的是旷视把结果返回的json字符串
{"image_id":"AvOVDQxfja9cu+rL0mYurQ==", "result":[{"child-objects": [{"child-objects": [],"position": [{"y": 319, "x": 123},{"y": 319, "x": 137}, {"y": 333, "x":137}, {"y": 333, "x": 123}], "type":"character", "value": "m"}],"position": [], "type": "textline","value": "m"}, {"child-objects":[{"child-objects": [], "position": [{"y": 134,"x": 42}, {"y": 133, "x": 61}, {"y":153, "x": 63}, {"y": 155, "x": 43}],"type": "character", "value":"\u53e5"}, {"child-objects": [], "position":[{"y": 132, "x": 66}, {"y": 134, "x":86}, {"y": 154, "x": 84}, {"y": 152,"x": 64}], "type": "character","value": "\u5bf9"}, {"child-objects": [],"position": [{"y": 133, "x": 112},{"y": 135, "x": 133}, {"y": 156, "x":131}, {"y": 154, "x": 110}], "type": "character","value": "\u8d77"}], "position": [],"type": "textline", "value":"\u53e5\u5bf9\u8d77"}, {"child-objects": [{"child-objects":[], "position": [{"y": 136, "x": 22},{"y": 137, "x": 34}, {"y": 149, "x":33}, {"y": 149, "x": 21}], "type":"character", "value": "\u4e00"}],"position": [], "type": "textline","value": "\u4e00"}, {"child-objects":[{"child-objects": [], "position": [{"y": 157,"x": 17}, {"y": 156, "x": 39}, {"y":178, "x": 41}, {"y": 180, "x": 19}],"type": "character", "value": "\u6ca8"},{"child-objects": [], "position": [{"y": 158,"x": 55}, {"y": 157, "x": 77}, {"y":178, "x": 78}, {"y": 179, "x": 56}],"type": "character", "value": "1"},{"child-objects": [], "position": [{"y": 157,"x": 88}, {"y": 158, "x": 108}, {"y":179, "x": 108}, {"y": 179, "x": 87}],"type": "character", "value":"\u5f53"}, {"child-objects": [], "position":[{"y": 157, "x": 112}, {"y": 160, "x":133}, {"y": 180, "x": 131}, {"y": 178,"x": 110}], "type": "character","value": "\u521d"}, {"child-objects": [],"position": [{"y": 159, "x": 137},{"y": 158, "x": 156}, {"y": 178, "x":157}, {"y": 179, "x": 137}], "type":"character", "value": "\u7684"},{"child-objects": [], "position": [{"y": 158,"x": 161}, {"y": 158, "x": 177}, {"y":178, "x": 178}, {"y": 179, "x": 161}],"type": "character", "value":"\u7231"}, {"child-objects": [], "position":[{"y": 158, "x": 183}, {"y": 158, "x":203}, {"y": 178, "x": 203}, {"y": 178,"x": 183}], "type": "character","value": "\u4f60"}], "position": [],"type": "textline", "value":"\u6ca81\u5f53\u521d\u7684\u7231\u4f60"}, {"child-objects":[{"child-objects": [], "position": [{"y": 136,"x": 90}, {"y": 135, "x": 106}, {"y":152, "x": 107}, {"y": 153, "x": 91}],"type": "character", "value":"\u4e0d"}], "position": [], "type": "textline","value": "\u4e0d"}], "request_id":"1501724700,03d59c8d-3fd1-447e-88d4-553d9b9814a7","time_used": 771}
阿里识别出来的结果
句对7网当
下面是返回结果的json字符串
{
"msg":"OK",
"code":200,
"data":[
{
"msg":"OK",
"code":200,
"dataId":"763a141f-c6f7-4c4e-a8c5-b3898d1d2d65",
"results":[
{
"rate":98.9,
"suggestion":"pass",
"label":"normal",
"scene":"porn"
},
{
"ocrData":[
"句对7网当"
],
"rate":99.91,
"suggestion":"review",
"label":"ocr",
"scene":"ocr"
},
{
"rate":99.91,
"suggestion":"pass",
"label":"normal",
"scene":"qrcode"
},
{
"rate":99.91,
"suggestion":"pass",
"label":"normal",
"scene":"sface"
}
],
"taskId":"imgSqAsQ6LAOf6s4TV0V7Oc2-1nqn0g",
"url":"https://timgsa.baidu.com/timg?image&quality=80&size=b9999_10000&sec=1501734176984&di=3490f64809b7b6aad63248c1781b2297&imgtype=0&src=http%3A%2F%2Fcdn.duitang.com%2Fuploads%2Fitem%2F201405%2F20%2F20140520230352_LSSmd.thumb.224_0.jpeg"
}
],
"requestId":"6F338191-17FD-4A7C-ABA7-21D0AE87DADE"
}
百度识别的结果采用网络图片文字识别发现这个的识别度比通用文字识别度高
句对不起
讽刺了当初的爱你
返回的json字符串
{"direction": 0, "words_result_num": 2,"words_result": [ { "words": "句对不起", "probability": {"variance": 0.005448, "average": 0.95525, "min":0.827484 } }, { "words": "讽刺了当初的爱你", "probability": {"variance": 0.002724, "average": 0.953231, "min":0.868461 } } ] }
上面三个api虽然每个都没完整的识别出来不过目前看到还是百度的识别率最高不过阿里的有一个好处就是支持异步的因为图片转文字如果文字多的情况下转换时间还是比较长的对于实时性不高的项目来讲还是不错的不然需要自己实现异步比如用消息中间件让
单独一个系统处理转换然后在这个系统处理完再把结果返回
下面测试其他的图片
百度结果
的说抢了
Do
也许是你了
三升
旷视结果
提示图片太大无法解析
阿里结果
C2记心戎9也许是1T6了三i
只能说复杂的都很烂
图片
百度结果
懂我的人,不必解释。不懂我的人,何必解释。
旷视结果
懂我的人不必解释不懂我的人何必解释
阿里结果
懂我的人不必解释0不懂我的人何必解释
字体普通的解析看来都差不多
腾讯也有个orc 不过前面测试以后觉得百度的不错所以这个就没进行测试了